hen it comes to online movie rentals there are 2 big players:  Blockbuster Online and Netflix.  So the question is:  "Which is better?"  This is the question we wanted to know.  Getting the answer wasn't so difficult.  After all, there are millions of clients of each service to survey.  However, the answer is not nearly as simple as we expected.  It seems that each service has local offices shipping movies direct to you.  The staff, location, weather, time of year, and numerous other factors can impact the performance of each service.  The number one factor is location.  So who  do you pick?  That's easy! Continued below...


Movie Rental Company

Rank

Unlimited Pricing

Movie Selection

Speed of Delivery

Free Trial

Adult Titles

XBox/PS2

Learn More

Comments

Trade DVDs at Peerflix #1 $0.00/mo 60,000+ 4.2 Days Always Free Great DVD Trading Site.  No monthly fee. Trade with other users for under $1!

#2*

$8.99/mo

85,000+

2.4 Days

14 Days

Excellent pricing. Preferred by pure movie enthusiasts. Usually fastest del.**

#3*

$9.99/mo

75,000+

2.6 Days

14 Days

2 in-store exhanges/mo. 2nd fastest delivery.  Great for gamers & movie buffs.

#4 $9.98/mo

60,000+

4.8 Days No, but easy to cancel. Plan includes 3 at-a-time rentals, great value! Outstanding selection.

#5

$9.99/mo

25,000+

4.2 Days

No, but easy to cancel.

Delivery times faster on East Coast. If you live near MD you might want to try this service.

#6

$13.99/mo

10,000+

5.3 Days

10 Days.

#1 choice for Chinese, Japanese, and Korean titles.

* Note: Ratings between top 2 vary widely based on location - see below.

What do FlickWatcher Stars Mean?

5 stars

Amazing.  Leader of the category.

4.5 stars

 

Almost perfect  satisfaction rate.

4 stars

Usually much better than expected.

3.5 stars

Great  substantially above average.

3 stars

Satisfying  Above the industry average.

2.5 stars

 

Average.   We don't recommend settling.

2 stars

Acceptable Many better choices on the market.

1.5 stars

Poor.  Keep looking you will find it's unacceptable.

1 star

Flawed.  Recommend you avoid at all costs.

 
Continued from the top...

Peerflix offers DVD owners the opportunity to trade DVD's that you own.  Peerflix does not offer rentals but becoming a Peerflix Community member is free.  If you have DVD's that you no longer watch and would like to trade them for new DVD's then this is the place for you.  Since Peerflix Community members ship the DVD's directly from their home delivery time can vary.  The Peerflix Community is constantly growing and is an extremely affordable option to DVD rentals.  Cost is .99 for each transaction.

If you are interested purely in movies and non-adult DVD's then we highly recommend you sign up for BOTH free trials from Blockbuster and Netflix.  Only by trying each of them will you discover who ships faster in your location.  You have nothing to lose, so sign-up and test them out.  Make sure you order equally high demand new releases from each service.  Judge them on both speed to get to you and speed of getting back into their system freeing up the next movie in your queue.  Most will find Netflix to be the faster service, but in some areas Blockbuster may be much faster.

If Playstation and XBox games are important to you, then you will be most satisfied with Blockbuster.  Although Intelliflix and DVD Avenue offer games, they are not nearly as fast in getting them to you.  In addition, the high demand games are often a very long wait for Intelliflix and sometimes DVD Avenue.

If you are looking for adult anime then Intelliflix offers the biggest selection.  If you are looking for non-anime adult titles then both DVD Avenue and Intelliflix offer many choices.  If you live on the east coast, definitely consider DVD Avenue for speed.

eHit has made an excellent decision to target the Asian market within the U.S.  If you are looking for Asian language titles, this is the only game in town.  Their pricing is competitive, $13.99 gets you a 2 at-a-time plan.  This service is recommended for those interested in Asian language DVD's.  They will have a better selection (including Asian TV series and adult) than any video store, even if you live in an Asian community.

Intelliflix offers the most value based on price ($8.25 for 3-at-a-time) and they are tied for highest selection.  They also offer games and adult titles.  This all appears to make them the #1 choice for anyone.  However, we've found that many customers of this service found them to be much slower than Netflix and Blockbuster.  If you are seeking adult, adult anime, and games - this should be your #1 choice.  However, even then we recommend adding Blockbuster or Netflix for the regular movie titles.

About the Rankings...

Rank.  This was decided on a number of factors.  Most importantly, the speed of delivery and processing movies through the system.  We also factored in selection, value, ease of use, and customer service.  The results of our surveys generated a polarized satisfaction group.  Although Netflix etched out Blockbuster overall, there were many areas of the country where Blockbuster was the clear winner - try them both.  If you have an interest in Adult, Adult Anime, and/or Games then consider altering the recommendations to suit your interests.  Keep in mind, delivery time is the #1 issue for most people and either Blockbuster or Netflix will be substantially faster than the others in almost all cases.

Unlimited Pricing.  In the interest of accurate reporting we listed the lowest monthly rate for the "unlimited" plans.  "Unlimited" means you can rent, watch, and return as many movies and/or games as you like -- 1 at-a-time.  Intelliflix starts with a 3 at-a-time plan for $8.25 and eHit starts with a 2 at-a-time plan for $13.99.  If you only watch a couple movies a month, then Blockbuster and Netflix offer less expensive "limited" plans, meaning you can watch a few movies a month - visit their sites for details.  You can also upgrade your plan, for example I have settled on a 3 at-a-time plan from Netflix for $17.99/mo.

Movie Selection.  60,000 is a lot of movies, but so is 25,000.  Most people surveyed were 'very satisfied' with each companies selections.  You'll notice that Intelliflix only has 3.5 stars for selection, despite having the same number of titles as Netflix.  This is because many of those titles are on abnormally long waiting lists.  So, although technically they have a tie for #1 in this category, the titles are harder to actually get.

Speed of Delivery.  This is the 'make or break category'.  Nothing made customers happier or unhappier than the speed of delivery.  You will be happiest with the company that gets you your favorite titles quickest.  Depending on your location, that will either be Netflix or Blockbuster.  We wish there was a decisive outcome here, but the fact is:  the distribution centers vary in speed and distance from your house.  Try them both, you will quickly discover the faster service.

Free Trial.  This makes testing Blockbuster and Netflix very convenient and risk free for you.

Adult Titles.  Intelliflix and DVD Avenue both offer a large selection.  Intelliflix has a fan base for their Adult Anime selections.

XBox/Ps2.  Many customers swear by Blockbuster in comparison to other companies offering games - once again based on delivery times and availability of titles.

Comments.  The chart was designed to be quickly scanned for the key decision making information.  The comments are concise, relevant information for each service.  Please be sure to click the "Visit Site" button to get further information on the plans, pricing, and offers.

Final Thoughts.  You will most likely find either Blockbuster or Netflix to be faster in your area.  It's definitely worth your time to give them both a test-drive since they each offer free trials.

What is FlickWatcher?  FlickWatcher.com exists to provide quality content in a unique interactive magazine style format.  We are testing every aspect of this design to judge it's usefulness to you, the viewer.  Please use our links and buttons as you narrow down your choices so we can test and further improve our layout.

We hope this list of online rental services saves you time and helps you make your decision.  Please think of us down the road after you've made your choice. Send us an email with a review of the company you decided to use.  Email us at:  admin@FlickWatcher.com

Thanks for stopping by!

-FlickWatcher.com

Visit the FlickWatcher Blog

All rights reserved 2007.  No part of this site may be reproduced without written consent from FlickWatcher.  Feel free to link this page.